PolityIndia

Shah Rukh Khan - IGNORANCE Personified!

  • Created on Friday, 03 June 2011 10:17
  • Published on Friday, 03 June 2011 10:17
  • Written by Punyatma Sharan, Founder/CEO - PolityIndia.Com, has a BA (Political Science) from India and MBA (Finance) from USA.

srkThere is no doubt that the Indian public is very frustrated with all the scams going on in the country '“ perpetrated upon us by politicians of different political parties.

We saw some hope in the fight against corruption...the movement getting help from Anna Hazare, Baba Ramdev and others. At this time, we get a statement from actor Shah Rukh Khan saying that Baba Ramdev's proposed hunger strike against corruption and repatriation of black money stashed in foreign banks is politically motivated and he would not support the agitation.

He said - "Koi support nahin karunga...unka agenda hai...jaise hi koi neta ho jata hai...voh yeh sab karne lagata hai (I will not support him...he's got an agenda...as soon as one becomes a leader...he resorts to such kind of agitation), Jo jiska kaam ho, usko voh karna chahiye...agar koi neta ban kar karna chahta hai toh that is not the right way to raise an issue (One should do what is appropriate for him or her. If anyone is trying to slip into the shoes of a politician, then that is not the right way to do it)". 

Baba Ramdev is a Hindu Yogi, who has gained popularity for his teachings of Yoga and Pranayama, and for his public stance on a number of political and medical issues, who has in the recent past taken on the role of a "sage soldier" (yoddha sanyasi) in a peaceful stance against corruption. He shot into prominence when he started the Divya Yog Mandir Trust with the company of Achary Bal Krishna. In 2003, Aastha TV began featuring him in its morning yoga slot. Within a few years, he had gathered a  following. He is known for his efforts of popularizing yog. The New York Times called him "an Indian, who built Yoga Empire, a product and symbol of the New India. His yog-camps are attended by a large number of people in India and abroad. Baba Ramdev has been associated with the 2011 Indian anti-corruption movement and was involved in the Jan Lokpal agitation. He plans to start an indefinite fast from June 4, 2011 to force the government to take steps to curb corruption, black money and bring back Indian money illegally stashed abroad.

In February 2011, he gave the following steps for eradication of black money:

1. Withdrawal and demonetizing of Rs.500 and Rs.1000 currency notes - so as to avoid misuse of unaccounted money and quick arrest of the entire locally circulated black money, bribing, and fake note traffic

2. Agree to and accept the U.N. Convention against Corruption '“ pending since 2006

3. Death penalty provision for the corrupt persons in the Indian Penal Code

4. Access, monitor and disrupt payment gateway servers enabling corrupt people to manage money in tax heavens

5. Scrutinizing accounts of people having credit/debit cards of foreign banks without any foreign work/relation

6. Disabling operations of any bank from a tax heaven country

Shah Rukh Khan's statement is either based on sheer ignorance or he has his own agenda. Either he is very childish even in his late 40's or his knowledge of social change is very minimal. His observation "Jo jiska kaam ho, usko voh karna chahiye...agar koi neta ban kar karna chahta hai toh that is not the right way to raise an issue' is an obvious reflection of his lack of depth to understand the complexity of the issue. 

The cancer of corruption in India has reached such a gargantuan proportion that it needs help from everyone in the country who is ready to raise their voice against it. It does not matter whether that person is a politician, social activist, academician, actor, businessmen etc. What does he mean when he says that everyone should do the work in their own areas? Where can we find people who have a Ph.D. and their specialization is '˜Eradication of Corruption'?

He should know that when Indira Gandhi declared emergency in 1975, actors Dev Anand, Pran, Shatrughan Sinha and Danny Denzongpa  were among  the first one in Mumbai to organize a rally against it. Late Jayaprakash Narayan raised the banner of revolt against Indira Gandhi which finally led to emergency. We all know that actors Sunil Dutt, Nargis, Shatrughan Sinha, Raj Babbar and others made a successful transition to politics. They were doing things which was not a part of their forte but a reflection of their social responsibility. Why Shah Rukh Khan did not oppose when Govinda was given a Congress ticket in 2004? SRK's proximity to the Gandhi family is not a secret. Why did he not tell Sonia Gandhi that Govinda is just an actor and he should just remain an actor. If he had done that, considering Govinda's level of intelligence, he would have done a service to the country.

Shah Rukh Khan has to realise that there is a thing called social responsibility. If you have money, social responsibility should also be supported by philanthrophic activities. SRK is estimated to be worth $555 million but I have never heard his name associated with any charitable work. He should realise that India is fine if he does not have these traits but he should not become an impediment for those people who are trying to think outside the box and trying to do something for the country. These people are the agents of change and are the impetus for others to think and join the movement against corruption. I am not a personal follower of Anna Hazare, Baba Ramdev and others like him but I am for all those people who are trying to bring any societal change. SRK should realise that there is more to life than putting your arms around Kajol, Rani Mukherjee and dancing around trees or on the top of a mountain. It is very easy to dress like a NASA scientist (Movie - Swades) but it is very hard to think like one. Until he gets hit by a stroke of intelligence and a sense of social responsibility, he should learn to keep his mouth shut. India can live without his irresponsible utterances. Even if this never happens, he still has Kajol and Rani Mukherjee to dance with and he can always perform at the private parties of big industrialists to augment his income. As a matter of fact, it is rather naive and stupid on our part to expect an intelligent analysis from a person who performs at these parties for money.

Comments  

 
# Dr Rajay Narain 2011-06-04 15:14
Very well drafted & written, covering all the past relevant events. I am personally against this idea of Satyagraha, in a democracy everybody should have the right to protest but there should be a proper way of doing it through a proper channel. The govt should not kneel down to every Baba's & Sadhu's Satyagraha, it sends a wrong signal and shows its weakness.
 
 
+1 # Sandhya Sinha 2011-06-04 17:24
I can't understand one thing being commonly said by people like Shahrukh Khan and Digvijay Singhji...Jo jiska kaam ho, usko voh karna chahiye. Has Kapil Sibal, Ravi Shankar Prasad or Arun Jaitley given up vakalat for being in politics? Has Shatruji, Raj Babbar given up acting for being in politics? Has Rajiv Pratap Rudy given up flying to be in politics? Serious politics is an extention of philanthropy. One does not need to give up his/her profession to be in politics. Yes, for dirty politics...one has to. Ramdevji has enough of his own credibility...h e does not need any endorsement from people like Shahrukh, whose service towards the nation is nil.
 
 
# Manidipa Sanyal 2011-06-05 05:03
At midnight, Baba was forcibly taken away by the police. His followers were driven out of the pandal. Where is our democracy? Digvijay Singh calls him a cheat. Why did Union Ministers go to negotiate with a cheat? As told by Digvijay that Ramlila ground was taken for yoga and was being used otherwise. The whole world knew about the fast and his demand. Why was he not stopped then? He was a threat to law and order, we are told. What law and order was being flouted at midnight? The way the whole episode unfolded, it is alarming. Peoples fundamental right to protest, has been violated. An emergency like situation has evolved.
 
 
# Piyush Sopory 2011-06-05 15:59
Shah Rukh is socially irresponsible and he is close to the Gandhi family. So, I consider this statement by him as politically motivated as well. For all we know, there could be his black money in the Swiss banks as well.
 
 
# Sanjay Pawar 2011-06-05 17:20
Punyatma, another great article. It is a great thing that the issue of corruption is being raised and debated in India. It does not matter who is raising the issue...whoever is doing it is doing a service to the country and anyone opposing that person is doing exactly the opposite. I have my doubts about Shah Rukh Khan's loyalty to our country.
 
 
# Vikram Gudakesh 2011-06-06 05:28
Very nicely put.
 
 
# Mukta Dhar 2011-06-06 22:42
Excellent analysis. Shah Rukh Khan is a passive Muslim fundamentalist.
 
 
# Sanjay Singh 2011-06-06 22:44
Even though SRK married a Hindu girl at a very young age, his loyalty towards India is very doubtful.
 
 
# Rakhee Sharma 2011-06-06 22:49
All Indians should stop supporting SRK and his movies. His approach is very detrimental to India's interest. Punyatma, kudos to you for writing this article.
 
 
# Sandhya Sinha 2011-06-07 07:52
Forget Shah Rukh. We pay him to entertain us and he is doing a fairly good job. But Ramdevji, he is good as a yoga techer and one must stop the buck here. I had booked myself at his Pitanjali yogashram, and my experience was very very uncomfortable there, so much so that I cut down my booking to just one day. The place is eerie, for whatever reason, I could not analyse. The canteens are let out to Balakrishna's salas. Preaching is one thing , Practicing another. No 'tailya padarth' consisted of only daliya(porridge ), rest were all jalebi, poori-bhaji, vada sambhar etc. Lunch was as good or as bad as any other canteen in our country. There were a list of at least 26 juices for various ailments, but in their canteen, only lauki juice was available. The place was full of contradictions, dirty linen, greedy and conspiring attendants and dislike for Balakrishna in particular in the local dwellers, who believed that Balakrishna had killed the Mahant to acquire land to build Pitanjali. Ramdev is just a puppet who HAS to dance on Balakrishna's tune as Bala has some skeleton of Ramdev's past in his cupboard. Had Ramdev got himself arrested on the dias, he would have become a rage and hero with the masses, but his trying to escape, that also in disguise, has made him fall from his credibility.
 
 
# Manidipa Sanyal 2011-06-08 06:35
I have a question for Sandhya. I respect her opinion of not liking Ramdevji's way of functioning. But isn't he a citizen of India? Does he not have a right to protest? About escaping, maybe there was a threat to his life. Even I am a non political person, not a supporter of Baba Ramdev. But you cannot suppress other peoples rights. It is unconstitutiona l. If he has unaccounted wealth, why was he not investigated earlier? Anybody protesting against the govt.is charged with unaccounted wealth. This is ridiculous.
 
 
# Sandhya Sinha 2011-06-09 06:50
I agree Manidipaji. The arrogance that the govt. is displaying is disappointing and the co-operation of the bureaucracy is not surprising, considering that the fight against corruption is directed towards them primarily. Topping the list is the police. Right from the beat officer to the minister, it is sinister rail, even the ones who do not wish to be part of it, HAVE TO fall in line lest their promotion and postings get effected. And don't get me wrong. I do respect Baba Ramdev for his contribution towards yoga and sensitization of core civic values. But the buck stops there. His militancy and aggressive approach towards tackling the issue is equally disappointing. It is a fact that it took a Gandhiji and a Subhash Chandra Bose to come together to free our country. A carrot (Annaji) and a stick (Baba) together CAN bring about the much desired change by the masses, but then, they must walk the path with caution and gravity.
 
 
# Ramendra Sinha 2011-06-11 12:24
Yes, corruption needs to be weeded out completely but not by such a charlatan. The question is what compelled Ramdev to get in the shoes of a politician? Was it the fear of unaccounted money which he has amassed by organising yoga camp or donation to his trust? (I am sure that for holding any camp he charges a stupendous amount and which is paid in advance to him. Now the people who get attracted with his style of yoga pay huge sum to get a space of 6X3. If at all he is genuine he sould not go charging the participation money). Anyway it reminds me of famous aphorism...'rel igion is the opium of the masses' and rightfully this man has encashed...afte r all only few years ago he started harbouring a dream of fighting election under the garb of rooting out corruption from India. Had he been anyway nearer to JP, he would have courted arrest and gone behind the bars. But no, like a sly fox he resorted to disguise in female attire to evade arrest...an action which should be condemned by all. So called Baba by millions is basically self centered and he deserted all those who gather at his call. He lacks leadership...an d such a person can be only called an opportunist.
 
 
# Purnendu Prasad 2011-06-12 00:25
Somebody should ask SRK how did he get Padmashree? Did he not donate INR One crore to bribe the government in power to get the coveted award? Another thing people should ask SRK whether cricket is his work? Let the people decide what is his true mettle.
 
 
# Amar Singh 2011-06-12 00:49
Punyatma, you are right about not expecting an intelligent analysis from a person who performs at parties for money. He has reduced himself to be a Glorifie d Tawaif.
 

President

pranab

Pranab Mukherjee (born 11 December, 1935) is the current President of the Republic of India. He was sworn in as President of India on 25 July, 2012, succeeding Pratibha Patil.

http://presidentofindia.nic.in

Prime Minister

manmohan singh

Manmohan Singh (born 26 September,1932) is the incumbent 14th Prime Minister of the Republic of India. He is the first Indian Prime Minister since Jawaharlal Nehru to return to power after completing a full five-year term. He is also the 12th Prime Minister under an Indian National Congress Government.

http://pmindia.nic.in/

Speaker (Lok Sabha)

meira kumar

Meira Kumar (born March 31,1945) is an Indian politician and a five time Member of Parliament. She was elected unopposed as the first woman Speaker of Lok Sabha on 3 June,2009. She is the daughter of an important politician - Late Jagjivan Ram.

http://speakerloksabha.nic.in/

Manifesto (Congress)

congress

2009 Elections

Aam Aadmi Ke Badhte Kadam
Har Kadam Par Bharat Buland

http://aicc.org.in/new/home-layout-manifesto.php

Manifesto (BJP)

bjp

2009 Elections

To Build a Prosperous, Powerful Nation, Recall India's Past

http://www.bjp.org/content/blogcategory/97/428/