PolityIndia

InshAllah, Good Riddance!

  • Created on Sunday, 24 April 2011 12:19
  • Published on Sunday, 24 April 2011 12:19
  • Written by Punyatma Sharan, Founder/CEO - PolityIndia.Com, has a BA (Political Science) from India and MBA (Finance) from USA.

TaslimaEven though I am neither a devotee nor a follower of Sathya Sai Baba, I respect everyone who think of him as their guru, a spiritual figure and an educator. He is described by his devotees as an avatar, godman, spiritual teacher and miracle worker.

The apparent materialising of vibhuti (holy ash) and other small objects such as rings, necklaces and watches by Baba has been a source of both fame and controversy '“ skeptics consider these simple conjuring tricks, while devotees consider them evidence of divinity. Sathya Sai Baba claimed to be the reincarnation of the spiritual guru, Sai Baba of Shirdi, whose teachings were an eclectic blend of Hindu and Muslim beliefs.

Among his millions of followers around the world is also a cricket player from India who has brought more laurels and prestige to India than anyone else in the recent history. He might even be bestowed with Bharat Ratna '“ India's ultimate civilian honour. He was getting ready to celebrate his birthday in a big way but postponed the plans because of  his guru's illness and unfortunately, Sathya Sai Baba died on the morning of 24th April, the same day Sachin Tendulkar was born 38 years ago. Needless to say, he was very upset and was praying for his guru until the end.

As soon as the news of the death spread acrooss the country and Sachin was seen in a state of mourning, we started getting tweets from Taslima Nasreen, a Bangladeshi ex-doctor turned author who has been living in exile since 1994. From a modest literary profile in the late 1980s, she rose to global fame by the end of the 20th century owing to her feminist views and her criticism of Islam in particular and of religion in general. Since fleeing Bangladesh in 1994, she has lived in many countries including India when she was asked to leave the country in 2008 where she was denounced by the Muslim clergy and received death threats from Islamic fundamentalists. She is the self appointed expert on secular humanism, freedom of thought, equality for women, and human rights. Her comments about Sathya Sai Baba were so derogatory that it has upset a lot of people. She even went to the extent of telling Sachin not to pray for him.

Taslima Nasreen, who is known more for the controversies chasing her than her literary skills, has been tweeting comments poking fun at Sai Baba. Some of her tweets are:

- "why shud somebody be sad abt his death. he was 86,shud b allowed to die. i was so dissappointd with sachin praying.crazy!"

- "Satya Saibaba died. He said he would die in 2022. But he died too early."

- "Hope no one will try to conceal small pellets of ashes at the base of their fingers. Then use their fists to powder the pellets and produce the flow of ash," 

- "Rasogollas and pumkins did not come from the fists."

- "There is another baba in the making. the kid is just 5 to 6 years old his training will take some time."

- "One godman gone but a thousands others will surface what a pity the bhakti business is quite lucrative."

Taslima, I feel your radicalism is standing on very thin ice. Just because you consider yourself an atheist does not give you the right to criticize and make fun of people who believe in something '“ dead or alive. Religious freedom and religious tolerance is a way of Indian life. Some people worship a piece of stone, some of them worship the sun or the moon and some may even worship a tree. It is their faith and beliefs which motivates their actions. We do not try to act righteous and tell others what to do. Every action in life is not an exact science where we have to come up with proof to justify it. Your indecent comments about Sathya Sai Baba is blasphemy and we feel that you have attacked our Indian way of life. Your statements and comments are always very obnoxious and scandalous. You have been called so many things by so many people. A group called you "an apostate appointed by imperial forces to vilify Islam". In October 1993, an Islamic  group called the Council of Islamic Soldiers offered a bounty for your death.

It is very ironical that the name of your first novel was Lajja (Shame) but you don't have an element of Lajja in your own thinking. How can you forget that the Indian government helped you and kept you in hiding around New Delhi for seven months when the Islamic clerics had issued a fatwa for you? Your lack of Lajja and your ungrateful behaviour reminds me of a member of my own family whose level of Lajja and level of ungratefulness is at par with you. What Indian government did for you...I did for my family member. Unlike you, even though I do not want to get personal, I want to say that you, during the period of 1982 '“ 1992, got married to Rudra Mohammad Shahidullah, Nayeemul Islam Khan and Minar Mahmood and all your former three husbands left you. I am sure that every time they think of you, their favourite three words are '“ InshAllah, Good Riddance!

Comments  

 
# Kalpana Singh 2011-04-25 18:39
Taslima Nasreen has no right to say anything about India's internal affairs. She should learn to keep her mouth shut.
 
 
# Sanjay Pawar 2011-04-25 18:43
It seems that she drove her three husbands away because of her irresponsible utterances. You are very right about her level of Lajja and ungrateful behaviour.
 
 
# Mukta Dhar 2011-04-25 18:46
There are some people who have no moral inhibitions about taking advantage of other people. Taslima Nasreen and your family member belong to this group. Punyatma, another great article .
 
 
# Tavish B Prasad 2011-04-26 14:06
In our democracy, every one has the right of speech subject to some reasonable restriction, I find no way out where any person shouldn't speak merely because she is pointing some notorious personality.... .
 
 
# Rakhee Sharma 2011-04-26 15:21
I was surprised to read the comment by Tavish B Prasad. Tavish, you cannot say anything in the name of democracy and freedom of speech. Taslima Nasreen is not even an Indian and not living in India. She has no business mocking and making fun of Sathya Sai Baba. There is a very big following of him in India and so many other countries and all these people are not stupid. Why don't you try saying nasty things about a Muslim clergy or religious leader and see what happens...they would issue a fatwa for you. Your comments are a reflection of your ignorance...you need to grow up.
 
 
# Sharmila Sen 2011-04-26 17:53
I came to know about PolityIndia.com in January and became a big fan of your writing. I am sending you my first comment. Taslima Nasreen is a woman of very messed up thinking. She has no authority to be critical of Sathya Sai Baba. You are so right when you say that she is attacking our Indian way of life. She has some issues with her past and her mindset is very confused. Even at the risk of being criticised by other women, I am ready to say that if three husbands left her within a time period of ten years, it is time for Taslima to go for a serious introspection of her own thinking.
 
 
# Madhu Srivastava 2011-04-26 23:47
A great article. I also admire Punyatma's writing because he says things as it is - there is no element of drama in his articles. Sharmila, you are so right in criticising Taslima Nasreen. In the name of women's lib, we should not let someone like Taslima talk rubbish. We have come a long way because we are aware of both - our rights and responsibilitie s.
 
 
# Sandhya Sinha 2011-04-28 14:12
A very well analysed article. I saw a play yesterday by Dinesh Thakur - jinne Lahore nai dikhya - a must see for all radicals. Taslima Nasreen writes or comments more to seek publicity rather than to drive home a point.
 
 
# Purnendu Prasad 2011-04-28 15:51
An excellent article.
 
 
# Naveen Vaidya 2011-04-28 20:20
Mr.Sharan, very nice article. Your usage of words is very powerful. I have mentioned to you before that I live in New York. We had a small anniversary party at our place last night. My uncle and his friends were also there. They are New York old timers and they know your family very well. They said that you used to live in New York in the 80's, got your MBA and then moved back to India. I also showed them your article on Taslima Nasreen. They said that you helped one of your family member at a time when his wife was going around and telling everyone in the Indian community that she was tricked into getting married on a false pretext that the husband is US educated and has a good job. They said that all his old friends have left him and he now preys on new people. They also said that if you are rich or you are a doctor or your wife is a doctor, he would somehow trap you.
 
 
# Rajani Sahay 2011-04-29 08:19
Nice article...what I feel is that some people do such things just to get noticed! See Taslima got a place in POLITYINDIA...d on't you agree that good gestures are not always noticed but negative comments get immediate attention?? Taslima is quite used to this kind of popularity...
 
 
# Tamoso Deep 2011-04-30 12:00
Hey, she did NOT tweet those...she just retweeted the tweet of others, and she did NOT tell Sachin not to pray for Sai Baba.
 
 
# Punyatma Sharan (Founder/CEO - PolityIndia.com) 2011-04-30 17:27
Ms.Tamoso Deep, your information about the tweets is not correct. All the Indian newspapers have news about her tweets and re-tweets. If you receive an email about a racist joke and you turn around and forward it to other people, you are as guilty as the person who sent you the joke. Our best wishes to you and everyone else in Bangladesh.
 
 
# Ajay Gupta 2011-04-30 17:32
A snake will remain a snake...
 

President

pranab

Pranab Mukherjee (born 11 December, 1935) is the current President of the Republic of India. He was sworn in as President of India on 25 July, 2012, succeeding Pratibha Patil.

http://presidentofindia.nic.in

Prime Minister

manmohan singh

Manmohan Singh (born 26 September,1932) is the incumbent 14th Prime Minister of the Republic of India. He is the first Indian Prime Minister since Jawaharlal Nehru to return to power after completing a full five-year term. He is also the 12th Prime Minister under an Indian National Congress Government.

http://pmindia.nic.in/

Speaker (Lok Sabha)

meira kumar

Meira Kumar (born March 31,1945) is an Indian politician and a five time Member of Parliament. She was elected unopposed as the first woman Speaker of Lok Sabha on 3 June,2009. She is the daughter of an important politician - Late Jagjivan Ram.

http://speakerloksabha.nic.in/

Manifesto (Congress)

congress

2009 Elections

Aam Aadmi Ke Badhte Kadam
Har Kadam Par Bharat Buland

http://aicc.org.in/new/home-layout-manifesto.php

Manifesto (BJP)

bjp

2009 Elections

To Build a Prosperous, Powerful Nation, Recall India's Past

http://www.bjp.org/content/blogcategory/97/428/